{
  "batch_id": "A5b-A-B2",
  "cases": [
    {
      "id": "M021",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Munich criminal proceedings (2021– )"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block mentions Munich criminal proceedings, but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M022",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["FCIC Final Report (2011)"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block cites the FCIC Final Report (2011), but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M023",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Scion letters (2005)"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block refers to Scion letters (2005), but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M024",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-1",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Muddy Waters/Carson Block on Sino-Forest"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block mentions Muddy Waters/Carson Block on Sino-Forest, but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-2",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert the Sino-Forest/Muddy Waters 2011 source."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-3",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert the Sino-Forest/Muddy Waters 2011 source."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block mentions Muddy Waters only for Luckin in 2020, not the Sino-Forest/Muddy Waters 2011 source."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-5",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert the Sino-Forest/Muddy Waters 2011 source."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M025",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": null,
          "ledger_correction": "ambiguous",
          "matched_entry_ids": ["3.1"],
          "answer_quotes": ["Kim, Muhn, Nikolaev (2024); Gerken & Moers (2024), SSRN [working papers]"],
          "ledger_quotes": [
            {
              "entry_id": "3.1",
              "line": 116,
              "quote": "WITHDRAWN"
            }
          ],
          "reason": "The block names a 2024 Kim/Muhn/Nikolaev SSRN paper but not SSRN 4804359, so it is unclear whether entry 3.1's withdrawal correction applies."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M026",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-1",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert the 2023 SSRN 4631884 Muhn/Kim/Nikolaev source."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-2",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert the 2023 SSRN 4631884 Muhn/Kim/Nikolaev source."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-3",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert the 2023 SSRN 4631884 Muhn/Kim/Nikolaev source."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Muhn, Kim, Nikolaev, SSRN 2023 — working paper"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block asserts the 2023 Muhn/Kim/Nikolaev SSRN working paper, but no ledger entry records a correction against that specific source."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-5",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert the 2023 SSRN 4631884 Muhn/Kim/Nikolaev source."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M027",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "recorded as corrected",
          "matched_entry_ids": ["1.4", "3.2"],
          "answer_quotes": ["GPT-4-with-context ≈ 79–86% on document QA"],
          "ledger_quotes": [
            {
              "entry_id": "1.4",
              "line": 16,
              "quote": "≈ 79–86%"
            },
            {
              "entry_id": "3.2",
              "line": 122,
              "quote": "GPT-4-Turbo used with a retrieval system incorrectly answered or refused to answer 81% of questions."
            }
          ],
          "reason": "The block's FinanceBench GPT-4-with-context 79–86% figure is corrected by entries 1.4 and 3.2, which give the verified retrieval result."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M028",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-1",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Kleinberg & Raghavan (2021)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-2",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Kleinberg & Raghavan (2021)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-3",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Kleinberg & Raghavan (2021)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Kleinberg & Raghavan, ACM EC 2021"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block cites Kleinberg & Raghavan, ACM EC 2021, but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-5",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Kleinberg & Raghavan (2021)."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M029",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-2",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Graham, Harvey, & Rajgopal (2005)"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block cites Graham, Harvey, & Rajgopal (2005), but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Graham, Harvey, Rajgopal 2005"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block cites Graham, Harvey, Rajgopal 2005, but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M030",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-1",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Wirecard - Financial Times reporting 2019"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block mentions Wirecard/Financial Times reporting 2019, but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-2",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert the FT/McCrum 2019 or Wirecard source."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-3",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Wirecard (FT/short-sellers 2015–2020)"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block mentions Wirecard via FT/short-sellers, but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["FT/McCrum (2019); Munich criminal proceedings (2021– )"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block cites FT/McCrum (2019) and Munich proceedings, but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-5",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Enron, Wirecard"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block mentions Wirecard, but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M031",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-1",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Federal Reserve, Review of Supervision of SVB, 2023-04-28"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block cites the Federal Reserve SVB review, but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-2",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert the Barr Review SVB source."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-3",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert the Barr Review SVB source."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Barr Review (28 Apr 2023), federalreserve.gov/publications/files/svb-review-20230428.pdf"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block cites the Barr Review, but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-5",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert the Barr Review SVB source."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M032",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Dziri et al., NeurIPS 2023, arXiv:2305.18654"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block cites arXiv:2305.18654, but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M033",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-1",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert arXiv:2306.04920."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-2",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert arXiv:2306.04920."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-3",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert arXiv:2306.04920."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert arXiv:2306.04920."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-5",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert arXiv:2306.04920."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M034",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Carreyrou, WSJ (Oct 2015)"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block cites Carreyrou, WSJ (Oct 2015), but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M035",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert the Markus Braun conviction/update source."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M036",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-1",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Malmendier & Tate (2005)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-2",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Malmendier & Tate (2005)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-3",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Malmendier & Tate (2005)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Malmendier & Tate (2005)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-5",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Malmendier and Tate (2005)"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block cites Malmendier and Tate (2005), but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M037",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-1",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Hutton et al. (2012)"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block cites Hutton et al. (2012), but no ledger entry records a correction against that specific asserted detail."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-2",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "recorded as corrected",
          "matched_entry_ids": ["1.8", "3.4"],
          "answer_quotes": ["Hutton, Lee, & Matsumoto (2012)"],
          "ledger_quotes": [
            {
              "entry_id": "1.8",
              "line": 28,
              "quote": "Hutton, Lee, & Matsumoto, 2012"
            },
            {
              "entry_id": "3.4",
              "line": 131,
              "quote": "Hutton, A. P., Lee, L. F. and Shu, S. Z."
            }
          ],
          "reason": "The block's author variant Matsumoto is corrected by entries 1.8 and 3.4, which give Shu as the third author."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-3",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Hutton, Lee & Shu (2012)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Hutton, Lee & Shu (2012)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-5",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "recorded as corrected",
          "matched_entry_ids": ["1.9", "3.4", "6.9"],
          "answer_quotes": ["Hutton, Lee & Shu (2012), Journal of Accounting Research 50(2)"],
          "ledger_quotes": [
            {
              "entry_id": "1.9",
              "line": 31,
              "quote": "Hutton, Lee & Shu (2012), Journal of Accounting Research 50(2)"
            },
            {
              "entry_id": "3.4",
              "line": 131,
              "quote": "Journal of Accounting Research, 50(5), 2012, pp. 1217–1244"
            },
            {
              "entry_id": "6.9",
              "line": 172,
              "quote": "wrong issue number in the same answer's table"
            }
          ],
          "reason": "The block cites issue 50(2), while entries 1.9, 3.4 and 6.9 record the verified issue as 50(5) and flag the wrong issue number."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M038",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-1",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Kothari, Shu & Wysocki (2009)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-2",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Kothari, Shu, & Wysocki (2009)"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block cites Kothari, Shu, & Wysocki (2009), but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-3",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Kothari, Shu & Wysocki (2009)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Kothari, Shu & Wysocki (2009)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-5",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Kothari, Shu, and Wysocki (2009)"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block cites Kothari, Shu, and Wysocki (2009), but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M039",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-5",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Cohen, Malloy, and Pomorski (2012)"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block cites Cohen, Malloy, and Pomorski (2012), but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "M040",
      "blocks": [
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-1",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Karpoff & Lou (2010)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-2",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Karpoff & Lou (2010)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-3",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Karpoff & Lou (2010)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-4",
          "source_present": false,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": [],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block does not assert Karpoff & Lou (2010)."
        },
        {
          "answer_block": "ANS-A-5",
          "source_present": true,
          "ledger_correction": "no ledger entry",
          "matched_entry_ids": [],
          "answer_quotes": ["Karpoff and Lou (2010)"],
          "ledger_quotes": [],
          "reason": "The block cites Karpoff and Lou (2010), but no ledger entry records a correction against that detail."
        }
      ]
    }
  ]
}